Share on pinterest

Best Dog-Safe Peanut Butter

The best dog safe peanut butter is Teddie Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter.

You probably know as well as I do that not everything is safe for your dogs to consume, even though they might enjoy its taste. One of such things is peanut butter. I’m not saying you can’t feed your pets some, you just have to be sure which best dog-safe peanut butter brand to feed to them.

This section talks about the best brands of peanut butter the market has to offer. We’ll show you the overall best option of peanut butter for your canines, the best choice when it comes to choosing a pocket-friendly option, as well as other brands that you should definitely know about.

Budget Conscious Pick

Kong Real Peanut Butter Tube

Our Top Pick

Teddie Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter

Readers Pick

Bark Bistro Company Raw Peanut Butter:

01 Teddie Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter

This brand has been in existence since 1925, little wonder why it ended up being our overall favorite choice for you. This particular spread is manufactured with peanuts organically grown in the US and comes in two sizes; 16oz and 26oz. It is non-GMO verified and gluten-free.

It is rich in taste and contains vitamins D & E as well as other important ingredients which are important for your dog’s nourishment. Made from only natural ingredients and with no added preservatives, this is probably the best option the US market has to offer you. 

One significant thing about the Teddie Smooth Peanut butter is, it’s not only suitable for your dog because it’s also perfect for human consumption. It even has the salted and unsalted variants. Having this product in your shelf saves you from the stress of buying a separate peanut butter for your family’s consumption as well as your pet’s. 

  • This is arguably one of the oldest peanut butter brands in the USA and is highly trusted by elite athletes, fitness fanatics, families and individuals alike. Plus, why have two or more different jars of peanut butter when you can have one that’s good enough for all purposes?

02 Kong Real Peanut Butter Tube

If you’re on a budget, then you would love this option. With less than ten bucks, you can get your hands on at least one of these 5oz peanut butter spreads. This preservative-free brand of peanut butter is not only delicious but it contains essential oils that will benefit your furry friends. 

Not only is this choice pocket friendly, it helps to maintain proper hygiene. You know how messy it can be while dealing with peanut butter, don’t you? With its tube-like design, Kong Real Peanut butter makes it easy for you to dispense just the right amount of peanut butter for your pet’s consumption without creating a mess.

Why we recommend – While purchasing this product, you get the chance to acquire a dog toy which actually compliments the use of the peanut butter itself. Which means your dog doesn’t only get a treat, but also the opportunity to have a new toy. Not to mention, it’s the cheapest choice you will find in the market today.

  • With the same price any other brand will cost, you can get more than one tube of this peanut butter and a dog toy to go with it. If that isn’t a win-win situation, I don’t know what is.

03 Bark Bistro Company Raw Peanut Butter

There are only two main ingredients in this brand of peanut butter; dry, roasted and unsalted peanuts as well as wildflower honey. Every ounce of this spread contains healthy fat, antioxidants, vitamins and proteins that can help your pooch. 

This peanut butter from the Bark Bistro Company also comes in three other flavors namely; barkin’ banana, pumpkin pup and the flax’n fido. This gives a wide range of options for your best animal friend to choose from. You can never go wrong with this brand of peanut butter.

  • This brand gives you a variety of flavors for your dog to choose from and is an all-time favorite.

04 Kong Stuff’N Easy Peanut Butter Treat

Just like the Kong Real Peanut Butter Tube, this product from the same manufacturer has a hassle-free characteristic. It comes in a container that has a nozzle which allows you use it without having to worry about creating a mess. And it’s best used together with a Kong dog toy. 

This brand is made with quite a number of ingredients which include milk, soybean oil, whey, protein concentrates and many more other ingredients. Unlike the other brands in this list, this brand contains preservatives as well as artificial peanut butter flavor. That’s not to say the quality of its taste is any less.

  • This product can help you solve two problems at the same time. From purchasing this Kong product, you get a delicious treat as well as the opportunity to give your dog something to play with in its spare time.

05 Peanut Butter Filled Cow Hooves

You’re probably wondering, “cow hooves”? You’d be surprised how more beneficial those nasty-looking things can be to your dog. These bony hooves are gotten from well fed cows and have gone through proper processing to ensure they are consumption-safe. This masterpiece is made in USA and is every doggies dream come true.

The combination of a peanut butter and a piece of bone couldn’t be more appealing to your pet. After managing to lick every ounce of peanut butter in the hooves, your furry friend still has the bone to keep it occupied for hours. Another beneficial thing is, chewing on the bone helps maintain and improve your dog’s dental health. 

  • Not only does this product keep your dog busy thereby allowing you free time to focus on other things, it keeps them satisfied and healthy as well. You also save yourself some money from trips to the vet because of dental issues.

06 US American Dog Treats Bully Sticks Peanut Butter

This is another product produced within the United States. It is made from blanched peanuts that have been slightly roasted to bring out that savory taste that your dog enjoys. This non-GMO product contains in it healthy fats, vitamins B and E, as well as niacin. It’s a great source of protein too. 

Also part of the ingredients in this product are bully sticks which are made in-house from Black Angus bulls raised in the US. This peanut butter is a great option to help administer your dog’s medication. Just hide any pill in a spoonful of this and watch your dog gobble it all up.

  • Based on a lot of reviews from customers, this peanut butter has become a favorite amongst many. Its taste is unique and provides adequate nourishment to you pets.

Buyers Guide

Best Dog-Safe Peanut Butter Buyer’s Guide

Why you can’t feed just any type of peanut butter to your dog?

You should know by now that not all types of foods can be consumed by your pets. Just like how it’s unsafe to feed your dog chocolate, it’s also not advisable to whip out any brand of peanut butter to treat your dog with. And the reason for this can be summarized in one word – XYLITOL. 

Xylitol is a common substance used as a substitute for sugar in a lot of edible food items. As a matter of fact, it’s meant to have significant dental benefits and also reduces the risk of diabetes in humans. It can be consumed by humans without worry but can be extremely dangerous when consumed by dogs. To explain how dangerous xylitol is to your dog, here’s a brief illustration. 

Consuming as little as 1.5grams of xylitol can bring about a rapid reduction in a dog’s sugar level and cause symptoms that can lead to a seizure. If a dog weighing about 30 pounds consumes just 6.8grams of this substance, it can cause a severe damage to its liver cells. Whereas it will take the consumption of 150grams of chocolate to bring about a similar results in a dog’s system. 

Things you need to know about peanut butter before feeding it to your dog

You would agree with me that peanut butter tastes really good. Maybe not to you, but your dog definitely thinks it does and that’s why they can never get enough of it. But you need to know that as nourishing as it might be, too much of it could spell doom for your pooch. Not only does it contribute to the build-up of excess weight in developing dogs, it isn’t the best treat for elderly dogs and should be avoided altogether.

Some dogs are naturals prone to some diseases and feeding them peanut butter will be doing them more harm than good. Dogs like Collies, King Charles Spaniels, Yorkshire Terriers and Miniature Schnauzers are susceptible to pancreatitis and adding unnecessary weight could be detrimental to their well-being. If you’re unsure of what kind of diseases your dog could be prone to, you are advised to visit your vet for more information. 

Now that you know the most important, there’s one more bit of information you might find helpful. If you have ever stored peanut butter before, I’m sure you would agree with me that it gets annoying when you open your jar and find the top layer laden with oil with the thick paste submerged below it. To reduce the occurrence of this, all you need to do is properly mix your jar of peanut butter before storage.

Is homemade peanut butter even an option?

Not a lot of people have ever considered this, maybe because it’s less stressful getting what you need off a shelf than actually making it yourself. Or maybe most people just don’t think it’s an option they can exploit because they never saw it as doable. But making peanut butter for your dog’s consumption can be really cheap and an overall fun experience. 

One advantage about making your own peanut butter at home is, you know for a fact that all the ingredients used are totally organic. And you can also ensure that no preservatives are added to your mixture. This will cancel out any worries you would usually have about your dog having any kind of food poisoning. You can even get experimental with the process by adding other ingredients that could be beneficial to your furry pal. 

Making homemade peanut butter is actually very simple. The only ingredient you really need is unsalted peanuts. You can decide to infuse some additional flavor by adding a bit of honey, sunflower oil and milk. You can as well add or substitute some of these extra ingredients with other nuts or fruits if you desire. 

Delicious peanut butter takes less than 10 minutes to make and here’s how it’s done. Pour your unsalted peanuts into a food processor or high speed blender and process until you have attained the desired consistency. Add other ingredients as you deem fit…viola! You’re all done. Yes, it’s that easy.


No doubt about it, your dog loves peanut butter and you can’t have anything against that. I mean you’re reading this and you probably love peanut butter too. It’s only right for you to find the safest possible way to indulge your pet because it means a lot to you, right? 

That’s why we have recommend our top pick here in this article. From its taste to its nutritional content, Teddie Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter has all that’s needed to satisfy your dog.

Like it? Share it!

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest

Recommended Reads

Leave a Comment

Rate This Article

0 votes, average: 0.00 out of 50 votes, average: 0.00 out of 50 votes, average: 0.00 out of 50 votes, average: 0.00 out of 50 votes, average: 0.00 out of 5 (0 votes, average: 0.00 out of 5)
You need to be a registered member to rate this.

Related Articles


Best Spill Proof Dog Bowls

We compiled this list of 14 of the best spill proof dog bowls on the market. These include our top pick, the WishLotus Floating Disk Spill Proof Water Bowl and other awesome alternatives like the ZOOZ PETS Snoopy 3D Design Weighted and CATPRO Spill-Proof bowls.

Read More »

Best Dog Travel Bags

The best dog travel bag is the Morpilot Dog Travel Bag Carrier, which is airline approved for carrying your dog. Other good options are PetAmi Dog Travel Bag and Top Dog Travel Bag Travel Set.

Read More »

Join Our Mailing List

Get the latest news on pets delivered straight into your inbox!